Cicis Pizza
Travel distance/time from Florida Delight (7.2 miles: 13 minutes)
We visited Cicis Pizza for the first time (November 2025) after having had it recommended to us, especially to try out their buffet.
There are several Cicis in the Orlando area but the one we went to was the one at Posner Retail Park as it is nearest one to our villa.
The restaurant itself is very basic and functional but it appeared clean. It was quite busy but still plenty of tables available.
Just like at any pizza outlet you can order a pizza of your choice, both to eat in or takeaway.
However what we had gone for was to try out their pizza buffet. This is available every day at a cost of $9.99 per adult or $5.99 per child for which you can have unlimited salad from the salad bar, pizza, pasta and dessert. As if this price wasn’t low enough on a Monday or Tuesday Cicis do a deal of anything you can eat buffet for $5.99 per adult and that is what we went for. The deal said it was time limited so you would need to check but go on their website, look under deals and it will be there if still on. Strangely they ask that you open the deal page on their website and show it to them when you are actually paying, which you do before you go to your table. They don’t accept a print out or screenshot of the deal.
Once you pay you can then get a plate and choose what you want from the buffet. The offering is range of salads from the salad bar as well as different dressings to choose from. Various different types of pasta and sauces. A wide range of pizzas all of which are cooked freshly in front of you and constantly replenished. Then dessert consists of chocolate brownies, cinnamon buns and a sweet pizza.
I think you pay extra for soft drinks but we didn’t want any so I am not totally sure about that.
You can revisit the buffet as many times as you wish while you are there and eat as much as you want. They ask that you use a fresh plate each time you go back up for more food.
Our overall verdict: Salads ok, pizza really nice. There is even a notice up saying if you can’t see your favourite pizza on the buffet let us know and we will make one whatever the toppings. The pizza was really good and far exceeded our expectations with it being so inexpensive. Definitely as nice as various pizzas we have had at other restaurants in the Orlando area. None of us tried the pasta as it didn’t look very appealing to us, but it may be very nice for all we know. We really liked the freshly baked cinnamon buns that were for dessert. Not so keen on the brownies and we didn’t try the sweet pizza.
As a good value, tasty meal it was great though and at that price you can’t go wrong. Worth checking out.
